The Best Indoor Grills of 2024, Tested and Reviewed

Best Overall

George Foreman Indoor/Outdoor Electric Grill

$184 at Amazon $140 at Walmart

Leave it to an icon to create one of the best indoor grills. This George Foreman frill has many of the line's beloved features: nonstick grill plates, a sloped surface, and the ability to actually sear indoors. On top of all that, it has more than enough room for you to grill for a party.

Once you're plugged in, the grill can be used at five different heat settings, thanks to its 1440 watts of power. The grill plate's surface temperature was able to around 600 degrees when we tested it, more than high enough for great sear marks on steak or fresh slices of zucchini. During all of the tests, the grill heated up evenly, with no extreme hot spots. While it did give off a little bit of smoke, it wasn't enough to set off any alarms. Most of the grease slid nicely down into the drip tray, though we did observe some splatter that got onto the heat control and the counter.

After testing was done, everything cleaned up nicely, including the grease tray, though you can't take the grill plate off the grill. This does come with a stand if you're looking to use it outside in nice weather. Though we recommend having a backup countertop or a sturdy table, since we found the stand to be a little unstable during use, though the grill never fell over.

Power: 1440 watts | Cooking Area: 240 square inches | Dimensions: 10.88 x 20.5 x 21.25 inches | Warranty: 3-year limited

Best Sandwich Press

Cuisinart 5-in-1 Griddler

Orig. $100 $90 at Amazon $85 at Wayfair $100 at Williams-Sonoma

The Cuisinart Griddler is designed to be a multiuse machine. Both grill plates are reversible, with a flat cooking surface on one side and a ridged cooking surface on the reverse side, so you can use it a panini press or an indoor contact grill. But that's not the end of its versatility. The hinge adjusts for thicker or thinner foods, and it also opens completely to a full 200 square inches of space. With a ridged surface, you have an open-top indoor grill. The cooking surfaces can also be a flat griddle, perfect for cooking pancakes or any foods where you want to avoid any chance of steaming.

Everything we tested on this came out wonderfully. We used it to grill up steaks, burgers, and chicken breasts, with each getting hot enough for fantastic sear marks. The controls are simple to use, with the griddle allowing for specific temperatures, while the grill/panini dial has four heat settings. Plus, the plates really showed their nonstick capabilities when melted-on cheese easily came right off. One of the only downsides was the bottom plates seems to heat more than the top one, so you'll need to be mindful when cooking.

We especially like that the drip pan is hidden away in the design, making this look sleek and compact when on your countertop. The plates can be placed in the dishwasher, and there are optional waffle plates available for crisp Belgian waffles.

Power: 1500 watts | Cooking Area: 200 square inches | Dimensions: 13.5 x 11.5 x 7.12 inches | Warranty: 3-year limited

Best Griddle/Grill Pan

Lodge Reversible Grill/Griddle

$48 at Amazon $59 at Walmart $47 at Wayfair

If you want to grill atop your stove, but also want to griddle outside on your grill, this large grill pan is a wise investment. The Lodge reversible griddle/grill can work on both, and even over a campfire during summer vacation. This 20 x 10.5-inch cast-iron grill will need to placed over two burners, but since it's cast iron, you know you'll get it hot enough for perfectly cooked burgers and hot dogs right in your kitchen.

We found it worked well for almost everything from large slabs of meat to generous amount of vegetables. It performed great for cast iron, and we used its inability to conduct heat to her advantage. Since this needs to straddle to burners, we created two different heat zones so dinner got to the table at the same time. When flipped over to its griddle, pancakes came out golden brown and personal pizza were easy to achieve in the oven.

Of course, due to the heavy cast iron, however, it may not be suitable for some glass stovetops. Being cast iron means it requires a little bit of extra maintenance with seasoning—grease does help with that—and its contact with water should be limited.

Material: Cast iron | Cooking Area: 20 x 10.5 inches | Warranty: Limited lifetime

Best Budget

Presto Cool Touch Electric Indoor Grill

Orig. $60 $56 at Amazon $60 at Walmart $56 at Wayfair

Whether you want to make grilled kebabs in the kitchen or do tabletop Korean BBQ at home, it's very possible to get an affordable indoor grill that performs well. This Presto model was one of the better performers in our Lab tests, and has the features you need.

First, the nonstick grilling surface can get up to 480 degrees, even when set to 400 degrees, though we did observe some hot spots. Regardless, we were able to achieve excellent caramelization on grilled flank steaks and chicken breasts. They also came off the grill with beautiful grill marks. While this doesn't have a lid or internal system to contain smoke, we didn't have any issue with smoking during our testing.

We did notice the base getting warm to the touch during grilling, so you'll need to be mindful of that. But everything clean-up nicely with a few pieces able to put through the dishwasher.

Power: 1300 watts | Cooking Area: 160 square inches | Dimensions: 18.43 x 11.25 x 2.18 inches | Warranty: 1 year

Best Smokeless

Power XL Smokeless Grill

Orig. $110 $103 at Amazon $120 at Newegg.com

Unless you enjoy the sound of the smoke alarm, indoor grilling involves being mindful of your smoke levels. For stovetop grill pans and countertop electric grilling, you can easily turn on your vent to help. But you won't need that addition with this smokeless grill.

Smokeless grills work by incorporating a fan to circulate any smoke or steam that forms so it can be captured in a water tray. With this, we found the water tray was a bit cumbersome when filled, but did its job. When the nearly-airtight lid was closed, smoke, steam, and heat stayed within the grill. When it comes to that heat, the grill can get up to 450 degrees, not hot enough to fully sear, but good enough for anything else you want to grill.

Since this has a lid during cooking, any sputtering grease is mostly contained. You will though have a big clean-up job when it comes to the numerous parts with nooks and crannies.

Power: 1200 watts | Cooking Area: 110 square inches  | Dimensions: 20 x 12 x 5.5 inches | Warranty: 90 days

Best Grill Pan

Le Creuset Signature Square Skillet Grill Pan

Orig. $225 $184 at Amazon $225 at Wayfair $225 at Williams-Sonoma

The high-quality cookware from Le Creuset is a perennial favorite of ours, so it was no surprise to us when this grill pan outperformed the competition during testing. The 10.25-inch pan features enameled-coated cast iron and grates high enough to allow for some air circulation underneath your food. This means your burgers will get amazing grill marks, instead of simply getting steamed.

Its slightly smaller size works to its advantage. Most of the pan had contact with our burner leading the cast iron to warm evenly across the surface. We were also amazed by how easy it was to flip our food without getting splattered or accidentally smooshing it against the side. Of course, this being cast iron means that it has enough heft to stay put after you place it on the stove or grill.

The enameled surface made this exceptionally easy to clean, no matter how much grease we made while cooking. One drawback though was the handle did get very hot—just keep an oven mitt around if you need to move it before it's fully cooled.

Material: Cast iron | Oven Safe Temperature: 500 degrees | Induction Compatible: Yes | Dishwasher Safe: Yes

Best Splurge

Kenyon City Grill

View on Amazon

The Kenyon City Grill looks more industrial than runway-model stylish, but what it lacks in looks it makes up in performance. It can reach temperatures over 500 degrees for excellent grill marks and performance similar to outdoor grills. Which makes sense, since this can be move outdoors when it’s too hot or too inconvenient to cook in the kitchen. 

While heat circulates until the lid when it’s closed, most of the cooking is from the heat of the grill grates. The grates are nonstick, which is important when it's time to be flipped. Like backyard gas or electric grills—or let’s face it, even your stove—this doesn’t have temperature marks on the control knob. It can take a short time to get used to how hot the grill should be for different types of cooking, but in no time we were flipping burgers and grilling chops with no problem. It’s also nice for toasting tortillas after the fillings are done. When done cooking, it’s important to turn the grill off or unplug it since there is no auto-shutoff or timer feature.

A rolling cart and a cover are available if the grill will be used outdoors, and a griddle plate is also available to make the grill a bit more versatile.

Power: 1330 watts | Cooking Area: 155 square inches  | Dimensions: 21 x 12 x 8.6 inches | Warranty: 3 years