The 8 Best Roasting Pans of 2024, Tested and Reviewed

Best Overall

Made In Blue Carbon Steel Roasting Pan

$139 at Amazon $149 at Walmart $139 at Madeincookware.com

Made In has quickly grown its reputation as a high-quality, chef-approved cookware brand and this roasting pan is just another example of why. It was designed in collaboration with Chef Tom Colicchio, co-founder and former head chef of New York City's Gramercy Tavern. Large enough for a 12-pound turkey, this premium carbon-steel roaster boasts excellent heat retention and proper seasoning creates a nonstick surface. The high sides are fantastic for encouraging even browning and the riveted loop handles are large enough for you to comfortably transport your pan with oven mitts on. The roaster also comes with a flat stainless steel rack to keep your meat or poultry aloft, while also allowing just enough space below for roasting veggies.

We found the pan to be easy to use, turning out crispy roasted potatoes with pillowy soft insides, and evenly cooked chicken in just over an hour. Thanks to its nonstick surface, we noted it was also incredibly easy to clean—the rounded edges also ensure that food doesn't get stuck in its corners (one of the pain points Colicchio wanted to remedy).

The pan is oven safe up to 1200 degrees Fahrenheit and can also be used directly on the stovetop—it's even induction compatible. Just like other carbon steel pieces, this pan should be washed by hand and seasoned regularly to maintain its nonstick quality. While it is on the pricier side, it's built to last and is a great investment for anyone interested in outfitting their kitchen with professional-style cookware.

Material: Carbon steel | Dishwasher Safe: No | Stovetop Safe: Yes | Includes Rack: Yes | Oven Safe Temperature: 1200 degrees | Weight: 5.56 pounds

Best Small

Farberware Nonstick Steel Roaster

$30 at Amazon Orig. $51 $46 at Walmart $30 at Target

If you're searching for a more compact roaster, this sleekly designed pan from Farberware should suit your needs. Measuring 11 inches wide by 15 inches long, this lightweight roasting pan still has plenty of space for a decently-sized rack of lamb or large chicken. Made of steel, this rack also has a nonstick coating that keeps food from getting stuck—helpful for when you're transferring its contents or cleaning up. The included chrome-plated rack will keep your protein raised, allowing you to keep your meats or vegetables from sitting in their juices if you don't want them to. While it isn't suitable for stovetop use, its maneuverability allows you to pour drippings into a saucepan to make gravy without being cumbersome.

This roaster did really well when we cooked a chicken and potatoes, offering plenty of room for even cooking (though not as much browning as some other models). Cleaning was a breeze thanks to the nonstick coating, and we thought it delivered great value considering its versatility and performance combined with a very reasonable price.

The shape of this pan also lends itself well to uses besides roasting—it can handle lasagna, casseroles, or even brownies. While the pan's maximum heat threshold—450 degrees Fahrenheit—is lower than others, it is still a great roaster that we recommend to those with limited space or for those who don't cook for a crowd very often.

Material: Steel | Dishwasher Safe: Yes | Stovetop Safe: No | Includes Rack: Yes | Oven Safe Temperature: 450 degrees | Weight: 3 pounds

Best Luxury

Hestan Provisions Stainless-Steel Nonstick Roaster with Rack

$140 at Amazon $220 at Wayfair $180 at Williams-Sonoma

Whether it’s a chicken a beef roast, or a turkey, this pan can handle it all. The rack is heavy-duty and sturdy, so it can handle the weight of whatever you put on it. It fits snugly into the pan, so it won’t shift around in the pan, keeping the roast nice and secure. The nonstick surface of the pan along with the heavy bottom means it’s much less likely you’ll burn the veggies or whatever is in the bottom of the pan. Plus, it’s super-easy to clean when cooking is done The handles are sturdy, so it’s easy to lift in and out of the oven.

Not just for roasting, this would be great for a party-sized lasagna or casserole, or for roasting vegetables for a crowd. We also used it to slow-roast a big batch of onions, and it held a lot and performed perfectly. We also tested the uncoated stainless-steel version of this roaster, and loved the performance just as much. If you don’t need a large roaster, a 14.5-inch roaster is also available, that would be great for chickens, roasts, and even for small turkeys.

Material: Stainless steel | Dishwasher Safe: Yes | Stovetop Safe: Yes | Includes Rack: Yes | Oven Safe Temperature: 500 degrees | Weight: 9.97 pounds

Best Budget

Rachael Ray 16" x 13" Roaster

$40 at Amazon Orig. $56 $40 at Walmart $40 at Target

Rachael Ray does it again with stylish and functional cookware at a very accessible price point. This nonstick-coated steel roaster measures 16 x 13 inches, sized large enough to hold a 20-pound turkey or roast. It features riveted stainless steel handles for secure transport in and out of the oven, large enough to grip securely even with oven mitts on. The pan comes with a reversible flat rack which lets you choose if you want your protein to sit higher or lower. The roaster can also be used directly on the stovetop to make gravy with pan drippings and is oven-safe up to 450 degrees.

This roasting pan did exceptionally well when we tested it—the potatoes browned and cooked very evenly while the chicken stayed juicy and cooked to perfection. We noted that the straight sides of the pan made it a little tricky to pour from, i.e. when transferring gravy to a bowl, but it wasn't a dealbreaker.

Due to its nonstick coating, this roasting pan is also very easy to clean by hand—important, since it's not dishwasher safe. While the pan's maximum heat threshold tops out at 450 degrees, it's enough to cover almost any roasting and baking needs and comes with a lifetime guarantee.

Material: Alloy steel | Dishwasher Safe: No | Stovetop Safe: Yes | Includes Rack: Yes | Oven Safe Temperature: 450 degrees | Weight: 4.86 pounds

Best Nonstick

All-Clad Stainless Steel Nonstick Roasting Pan

$200 at Amazon $200 at Williams-Sonoma $200 at Sur La Table

If you’re a fan of nonstick-coated cookware but also appreciate the aesthetic of stainless steel, this is the roasting pan for you. It features a luxe, highly polished stainless steel exterior and a PFOA-free nonstick-coated cooking surface. Owners of the pan say cleaning the nonstick interior is a breeze since food releases easily and it’s also dishwasher safe. 

This roaster did great in our Lab—roast chicken came out evenly cooked with a crispy skin on top, and the potatoes—while not as evenly crispy and browned as we prefer—were tender and creamy on the inside. We were also able to make gravy right on the stovetop, with excellent consistency and even cooking.

The pan is 16 inches long, has up to a 25-pound capacity, comes with a V-shaped nonstick rack, and is oven safe up to 500 degrees. Upright, riveted stainless steel handles provide stability in lifting heavy dishes out of the oven, and the high pan sides help minimize splatters. As with all nonstick cookware, you’ll want to avoid using metal utensils since they can scratch the nonstick coating.

Material: Stainless steel with nonstick coating | Dishwasher Safe: Yes | Stovetop Safe: Yes | Includes Rack: Yes | Oven Safe Temperature: 500 degrees | Weight: 9 pounds

Most Durable

Cuisinart MultiClad Pro Roasting Pan

$78 at Amazon $101 at Walmart $78 at Target

When it comes to roasting pans that will last, this model from Cuisinart fits the bill. This hefty pan weighs in at 10 pounds and comes with a U-shaped roasting rack that can hold a large turkey or roast with ease. The handles are securely riveted for easy maneuvering, and the triply-ply stainless steel construction is suitable for any stovetop, including induction.

We found this to be a really high-quality roasting pan with a strong performance. Roasted potatoes came out crispy and brown, while the resulting chicken was amazingly juicy. Even with a roast or chicken in the pan, there was still plenty of room to add our favorite root vegetables to cook at the same time. The heavy-duty construction means this pan is a real workhorse and can go from oven to stovetop for a thorough deglazing to create your favorite pan gravy. We also noted that the pan's bottom surface is flat from edge to edge, making it easy to deglaze and scrape, but want to caution that metal tools should be avoided to protect the pan's surface.

All in all, it's a sturdy roasting pan that is exceedingly easy to clean and seems to have the potential to last for a lifetime with proper care. If you tend to roast often and for a crowd, this is the pan for you.

Material: Stainless steel | Dishwasher Safe: Yes | Stovetop Safe: Yes | Includes Rack: Yes | Maximum Temperature: 500 degrees | Weight: 10 pounds

Best Oven-to-Table

KitchenAid Enameled Cast Iron Au Gratin Oval Roasting Pan

Orig. $100 $80 at Amazon Orig. $100 $99 at Walmart $80 at Wayfair

The Kitchenaid pan may have “au gratin” in its name, but it’s much more than that. Of course it would look pretty with an au gratin, casserole, or cobbler bubbling away, but it’s also the perfect fit for a roast chicken, with potatoes nestled along the sides for an easy dinner. Even better, it’s stovetop safe, so it can be used for sautéing vegetables or searing meat, and it’s just as handy for making gravy once the roasting is done.

Thanks to the enameled surfaces, it’s easy to care for, with no need for seasoning, although it’s not dishwasher safe. The shape is pleasing and practical—a chicken fits well, and it’s just as good for a pork or beef roast.

This is available in two attractive colors, pistachio or blue velvet, and it has side handles that make it easy to get in and out of the oven. It looks great in use, and is attractive enough for serving, too. When not in use, it can be used as a countertop fruit bowl, too.

Material: Cast iron | Dishwasher Safe: No | Stovetop Safe: Yes | Includes Rack: No | Oven Safe Temperature: 500 degrees | Weight: 6.6 pounds

Best Ceramic

Caraway Roasting Pan

$195 at Amazon $195 at Target $195 at Home Depot

If cleanup after roasting is a dreaded task, the Caraway roasting pan can easily solve that problem. Thanks to the ceramic coating, the pan is nonstick, so food simply sponges away when it’s time for cleaning. The stainless-steel rack takes a bit more effort, but it’s still fairly easy. In testing, a 13-pound turkey fit easily, even when we spatchcocked one, and it could have handled a larger one as well.

The large side handles make this pan easy to lift, and the handles on the rack make it easy to remove as well, to move the food for resting while the pan goes on the stove to make a gravy. Due to the excellent nonstick, drippings don’t brown during cooking the way they do in an uncoated pan. It’s a minor quibble, and the gravy we made was still excellent.

This comes in a variety of colors to match other Caraway cookware, or to add a pop of color.

Material: Aluminum, stainless steel, ceramic coating | Dishwasher Safe: No | Stovetop Safe: Yes | Includes Rack: Yes | Oven Safe Temperature: 550 degrees | Weight: 6.77 pounds