The 7 Best Salad Dressing Containers for Crisp Greens, Tested and Reviewed

Best Overall

Kolder Salad Dressing Mixing Bottle

$11 at Amazon

If you're looking for a salad dressing container that checks all the boxes, Kolder is a safe bet. With eight classic recipes printed on the side, you can say goodbye to tedious measuring forever. Recipes include caesar, French, Italian, Greek, vinaigrette, balsamic vinaigrette, honey mustard, and Asian—and there's even a "light" version of the bottle.

The 13-ounce bottle is a smart choice to make and store your homemade dressing with its tight-fitting lid that’s easy to screw on and off. During testing, we did note it has no pour spout or flip top, so the flow can be more difficult to control. One quick tip: When pouring dressing over salad greens, twist your wrist at the end to stop the flow from the bottle without spillage. The circular motion of the twist stops the flow of liquid and deposits it back in the bottle, much like the way it does for ending the pour on a wine bottle without dripping.

In our first test, we made the balsamic vinaigrette recipe on the bottle and found that the measurement markings eliminated the need to dirty an extra measuring cup. We noted the vinaigrette was a nice consistency and tasty prepared as directed. Our one negative was the narrow bottle opening required a funnel when adding thicker ingredients, like the dijon in the balsamic vinaigrette.

Another plus is that the permanent markings on this USA-made bottle won't fade over time. We love how both the top and bottle cleaned up easily in the dishwasher, and the recipe etchings on the bottle were still pristine.

Material: Glass | Capacity: 13 ounces | Weight: 8 ounces | Dimensions: 3.75 x 3.75 x 7 inches | Color: Off-white | Dishwasher safe: Yes

Best with Internal Mixer

Whiskware Salad Dressing Shaker with BlenderBall

$15 at Amazon $16 at Walmart View on Bed Bath & Beyond

You can certainly make salad dressing by shaking it in any convenient sealed container, but the Whiskware Salad Dressing Shaker makes the process faster and easier. It includes a round stainless steel wire ball that acts like a whisk right inside the container. Since it’s blended more efficiently, dressings stay emulsified longer. We put this claim to the test by making the same Simple Italian Salad Dressing in the Whiskware and a standard dressing shaker. We found the dressing in the regular container lost emulsification after 17 minutes and began separating while the dressing in the Whiskware remained fully emulsified for an additional 51 minutes. 

You can remove the ball for serving and storage or leave it in place to quickly shake the dressing again as needed. During testing, we noted the wide mouth of the container made for easy loading of ingredients, and appreciated the clearly marked measurements on the Tritan plastic carafe, alleviating dirtying extra dishes. We also recorded that the seal on the container remained tight with no leakage throughout shaking over three tests. 

The spout opens easily with one hand and closes automatically when released, eliminating accidental spills. We also loved the controlled flow of the dressing the pour spout afforded. The lid is best washed by hand so you can get into all the nooks and crannies, but we put both top and bottom through a dishwasher cycle and were impressed that all parts of the container were thoroughly cleaned.

Material: Plastic | Capacity: 2.5 cups | Weight: 5.9 ounces | Dimensions: 2.99 x 2.97 x 8.69 inches | Color: White, clear | Dishwasher safe: Yes

Best Small Shaker

OXO Good Grips Little Salad Dressing Shaker

$21 at Amazon $12 at Oxo $9 at Kohls.com

The OXO Good Grips Little Salad Dressing Shaker is a great choice when you want to make just a small amount of dressing. The 1-cup capacity lets you make single servings or just enough salad dressing for the family when you want to avoid leftovers.

This product has a leak-proof seal to shake and pour with confidence, and the wide opening lets you add ingredients with ease. We loved the clearly-marked measurements for both cups and milliliters—and lauded the convenience of not dirtying extra cups for measuring and the ample bottle opening for adding ingredients like lemon zest. Even better, there was no leakage while we vigorously shook the lemon vinaigrette.

For serving, the lever opens easily with one hand and flips back to seal so you can store the dressing in the same container. Though it easily performed these tasks for thinner dressings, when we loaded a chunky blue cheese into the container, the chunks of cheese could not pass the pour spout. 

Made from Tritan plastic, it is dishwasher-safe for easy cleaning. We confirmed that all parts, including the angled spout and gasket threads, were completely clean after a run through the dishwasher. One of the standout features of this model is the green, non-slip grip which fits comfortably in hand and stays secure throughout shaking three different salad dressings.

Material: Plastic | Capacity: 8 ounces | Weight: 4.6 ounces | Dimensions: 2.5 x 2.5 x 6.6 inches | Color: Green, clear | Dishwasher safe: Yes

Best Oil and Vinegar Set

Zeppoli Royal Oil and Vinegar Bottle Set

Orig. $29 $20 at Amazon $14 at Walmart

Oil and vinegar is a classic combo for salad dressing. We appreciated the included collapsible funnel for easy, mess-free filling. They’re also handy in the kitchen when you need to dispense oil or vinegar for recipes. The stainless steel rack looks attractive on the table or in the kitchen and makes the bottles easy to carry or pass around at the table.

For testing, we filled the bottles with avocado oil and red wine vinegar. The dual-spout design allowed us to dispense at customized flow levels over four bowls of salad greens without dribbles. We also loved the included rubber stoppers for preserving leftover oil and vinegar. The rubber stoppers seal tightly, and we noticed no leakage even after holding the bottle upside down for 15 minutes.

The one negative we found was the tall, slender shape of the bottle made it difficult to clean, even with a normal bottle brush. A tall, thin test tube brush solved the issue and passed through the spouts and gaskets easily.

Material: Glass | Capacity: 17 ounces | Weight: 2.5 pounds | Dimensions: 14.1 x 6.1 x 3.3 inches  | Color: Clear, black | Dishwasher safe: No

Best Serving Cruet

Anchor Hocking Presence Cruet With Stopper

$57 at Amazon $15 at Wayfair $4 at Farmandfleet.com

The sturdy handle and pour spout of a cruet, such as this one from Anchor Hocking, make it easy to dispense the right amount of dressing. The heft of the tempered glass felt durable, and the etching on the stopper made this an attractive choice for a serving vessel on a table. In tests, a funnel was necessary for both a thinner vinaigrette and creamy ranch dressing because of the narrow size of the cruet mouth. 

Oil and vinegar went in easily and poured at a nice flow over salad greens. The stopper provided a secure seal for storing extra dressing in the refrigerator overnight. It will also come in handy for serving syrups or sauces at the table. We used it to serve warm maple syrup for a pancake breakfast and found it poured well with very little dripping across six plates of flapjack stacks.

Cleaning the bottle was slightly onerous, however—we had to use a small, angled bottle brush to reach the widest parts of the cruet’s body. Despite the extra cleaning tool required, this was a smart choice if you are looking for the best salad dressing container to double as a pretty serving vessel.

Material: Glass | Capacity: 10 ounces | Weight: 4 pounds | Dimensions: 12 x 8 x 8 inches  | Color: Clear | Dishwasher safe: Yes

Best Nostalgic Favorite

Good Seasons Italian Dressing Mix, 2 Packages with Cruet

$10 at Amazon $28 at Walmart

Before salad dressing mixes were ubiquitous, Good Seasons sold its dressings with an iconic bottle that was appealing enough for serving. Today, the brand offers the same deal, although the cruet is a little different. Although there are measurement marks on the side of the bottle, they are not obvious quantities. The “O,” “W,” and “V” correspond to how much oil, vinegar, and water are required to prepare the included Good Seasons dressing packet. We made the Italian dressing twice according to box directions and cruet measurements with consistent, tasty results. When shaking the dressing, some leakage seeped out between the plastic top and cruet, but not much. 

We appreciated the sturdy glass cruet with its wide mouth and sloped body, but reported the plastic top seemed flimsy and was difficult to snap on and off. Beyond the included Italian dressings, we filled the bottle with a vinaigrette and a chunky blue cheese dressing. Across four tests, the mouth of the bottle was amply sized to add all ingredients without spillage or the need for a funnel. The flow of the vinaigrette was nice and controlled coming out of the flip-top spout, but the chunky blue cheese could not pass through the hole. This was easily remedied by taking the plastic top off and pouring directly from the container.

While cleaning, we found that a typical bottle brush was too big to fit into the cruet for washing, but a small brush easily passed the mouth and reached the entire glass surface. Without the plastic top on, this cruet was attractive enough to serve maple syrup, sauces, or dressings right at the table.

Material: Plastic | Capacity: Not listed | Weight: 2.8 ounces | Dimensions: 11.18 x 9.76 x 4.61 inches | Color: Clear, black | Dishwasher safe: Not listed

Best Basic

Norpro Salad Dressing Maker

$9 at Amazon $16 at Walmart

The Norpro Salad Dressing Shaker/Maker takes all the guesswork out of homemade dressing. The glass container has measurements for six different salad dressing recipes etched on the bottle. All you have to do is fill it to the lines, shake, and serve. There's no need to open a cookbook or search online for recipes and ratios.

The airtight lid keeps the dressing fresh when you make it in advance or need to store leftovers, and we loved the flip top spout for controlling dressing flow when pouring with no spillage. The recipes on the bottle include French vinaigrette, Italian herb, creamy caesar, sesame scallion, honey mustard, and creamy citrus ginger. We did note the narrow bottle opening made it difficult to load ingredients without a funnel, like the greek yogurt and parmesan cheese for a creamy caesar recipe. We also made the Italian herb and noted the bottle and top remained securely closed while shaking with no leakage. 

Plus, this shaker and maker combo is dishwasher-safe for easy cleaning. We tested the Norpro through two dishwasher cycles—both the top and container came completely clean with no damage to the recipe etchings.

Material: Glass | Capacity: 11 ounces | Weight: 8 ounces | Dimensions: 8.25 x 2.75 x 2.75 inches | Color: Clear | Dishwasher safe: Yes